This is the mail archive of the
gdb-patches@sourceware.org
mailing list for the GDB project.
Re: [RFA 1/2] mips: Switch inferior function calls to ON_STACK method.
Mark,
> > Thanks for this work -- can you give me a reference to some background
> > information as to why exactly we want to remove the AT_SYMBOL method?
>
> The AT_SYMBOL method relies on a magic symbol being present in the
> binarie that's being debugged. There is no guarantee that that magic
> symbol is actually present in your binary.
And failing that the executable's entry point. Actually I have yet to
see a binary that has that magic __CALL_DUMMY_ADDRESS symbol, so the
fallback must have worked pretty well. Interestingly enough it was the
MIPS target AT_SYMBOL was specifically added for:
http://sourceware.org/ml/gdb-patches/2003-08/msg00076.html
And that very patch regrettably removed the explanation of the actual
reason of the whole arrangement -- the need to be able to debug a program
in ROM that does not have an entry point (or I think, probably more
accurately, rather has a read-only entry point such as the reset vector,
so a breakpoint is not guaranteed to work there).
Of course ON_STACK solves that in a more general manner, so that's the
actual benefit from this change. That removes any doubt I might have had.
Thanks for your input, including your other comments.
Maciej